Showing posts with label Infringement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Infringement. Show all posts

Friday, December 12, 2014

The 'Mi' Trouble

The world of smartphones has witnessed constant growth and has become the subject of numerous infringement suits. Xiaomi is no stranger to controversies. As soon as the electronics firm entered the Indian Smartphone market, a few months down the line, has been blocked from selling handsets. 

At the crux of the matter, lies the infringement claims of eight registered Standard Essential Patents of Ericsson. The Hon'ble Delhi High Court has passed an injunction forbidding the firm from producing, building, importing or selling smartphones utilizing the Patent in India. India being its largest market outside China, this surely has come off as a blow to the infant company.

Xiaomi and Flipkart, e-commerce partner, have to announce how many devices have been shipped, so as to calculate the compensation due to Ericsson. In an earlier infringement suit against Micromax, Ericsson is to receive 1% of the selling price of the devices, by way of royalty, for use of latter's Standard Essential Patents. 

While thee court has directed the Central Board of Excise and Customs to stop the import of devices from Xiaomi, it is to be looked how the firm's legal team works a way out of this suit. 

- Bagmisikha Puhan




Saturday, November 15, 2014

Ghostwriting Troubles!!!

Ghostwriting is not a recent development, but it has been very much in practice since the days of Mozart. The Classical Era Composer was known for having ghostwritten music for wealthy patrons. Political leaders have been exploiting this avenue, along with many Executives and celebrities; who do not prefer to invest much of their time in relating to the public en masse, the lives they lead.

Recently, the erstwhile Chancellor of West Germany and the reunited Germany, Helmut Kohl, got into a legal tussle with his former Ghostwriter Heribert Schwan. After the fall out between Kohl and Schwan (publication of 3 books together), the ghostwriter has published "Vermachtnis: Die Kohl Protokole", recording many direct quotes of Kohl. Mr. Kohl had decided against the publication of the fourth book. 

Kohl in his interviews with Schwan had made very direct comments about the present German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, the former British Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher, and Mikhael Gorbachev too.

The former Chancellor has been successful in obtaining an injunction against any further printing of the book, which include the quotes of Kohl as recorded in the previous interviews with Schwan. The court has gone ahead in supporting Kohl's claims holding the ghostwriter's act to be an unlawful infringement of confidentiality, since the book has been published against the express wishes of his.

This is not the end of the tale, let's see how the story unfolds.


- Bagmisikha Puhan

Tuesday, September 9, 2014

Fair Use Defense

Fair use as a concept stands on very tricky grounds. One cannot just be sure if the ground will stick through as fair use or not. In the scenario where such a matter reaches the courtroom, the time and finances that are invested into settling the dispute, many a times outweighs the benefit reaped out of the use in the first place.

For all those people who have been taking shelter of acknowledgments and disclaimers are not really safe. The very fact that one has acknowledged the original author in his or her use of the protected work does not preclude the person from their liability in a suit of infringement.  The fact that the original author has been cited can support the author in his claim of infringement; if he chooses to retort to the claim of a person infringing upon his right of publicity.

The fact that a disclaimer has been added to the use of the protected work does not preclude the user from his liability towards infringement. A disclaimer stands to prove stronger grounds for fair use, but does not stand as a ground for defense in its own merit.


One of the best ways to avoid any claims of copyright infringement is to abstain from using the protected material without the explicit permission of the original author. Apart from the usual factors which are taken into consideration while judging an instance of fair use, consideration of acknowledgements and disclaimers proves to be a viable option for the courts. 

- Bagmisikha Puhan

Sunday, July 22, 2012

In Re EMC: Another Blow to patent troll

Hardly one year after passing of the American Invents Act which addressed some of the irritating habits of patents trolls now it is the turn of US Court of appeal for Federal circuit to address the menace of patent owners who uses patent litigation as a tool to make money from companies rather than entering into actual business.


On May 4th 2012, the Court of Appeal issued a blow to all Non-practicing entities who files multi- defendant cases as an effort to avoid the requirements of the America Invents Act. The Court in this case held that “Joinder” is not appropriate in multi-defendant patent infringement cases where only commanlity is alleged infringement of same patents. 

Oasis Research LLC, the plaintiff in the original suit is the owner of four US patents which deals with off-site computer data storage by allowing home computer users to remotely connect to an online service system for purposes of external data storage. Oasis Research LLC files a Multi – defendant patent infringement claim against the petitioners (defendants in original suit) as they offer online backup and storage though various websites.

The petitioners filed motions before the Eastern Texas District Court to sever the claims and transfer them to various jurisdictions. The District court denied petitioners motions reasoning that claims of Oasis LLC satisfy the transaction or occurrence test of Rule 20 of Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

Denying the reasoning given by the Texas Court, the Court of appeal points out that under the correct test of transaction or occurrence an existence of a single common question of law or fact alone is insufficient to satisfy the transaction- or- occurrence requirement. Thus mere fact that the infringement of same claims of the same patent does not support joinder, even though the claims would raise common questions of claim construction.

Further the joinder of independent defendants is only appropriate where the accused products are same in respect to the same patent. But commonality of patent alone is not sufficient to allow joinder. Commonality shall be supplemented with overlapping facts which give rise to each cause of action. Thus, if there is no actual link between underlying facts of each claim of infringement the independently developed products using differently sources are not to be considered as the part of the same transaction.

The 18 page ruling of the Court of Appeal is a serious financial blow upon the patent owners who count on using cheap litigation to win favourable settlements.

 By Nithin V Kumar

Thursday, June 14, 2012

Trade Mark Registration: Why it is Important?

Today Brands define a man's status. People go for those brands which promise them not only good quality goods but also good status. When a man enters a room, the reasons present there judge him based on the suit he is wearing- “is it Raymond?”- The brand of his watch- “wow its RADO” - the mobile phone he is using. Brands produced a new consumer culture, where the quality and credibility of goods and services where no longer judged by the traditional way, that is by really using it but by looking at the brand name. Brands project the personality of its source, if we put it in another way brands helps the consumers in identifying the source of the product. It is precisely for this purpose brands, or if we rather use the technical term, trademarks have been created.

This concept originated in the Middle Ages when craftsmen and merchants wanted to differentiate their products or services from those offered by competitors. Thus trademark simply means identity card of a company. This very reason makes trademark the most powerful Intellectual property concept. It cost company a lot of time, money and resources to build a credible trademark in the market. Trademark may be names, like well known mobile phone brand 'NOKIA' or famous service provider 'idea' with an inverted 'i' , it may be symbols, for example 'the apple' symbol of APPLE co.. Whatever form it may have it is the most powerful communication tool a company has to communicate with its consumers. A study conducted at Columbia University found that for consumer products and services, well-managed brands typically represent 50 to 80 percentage of the entire value of their companies. For business to business products and services, the percentages were lower but still significant - 20 to 30 percentage. Thus now we are in agreement to the fact that trademark is very important for a company. This importance of trademark makes it very vulnerable too, because there is a chance of others abusing your trademark, for their profit, by playing with your credibility and reputation. Nobody wants all of his/her efforts to go in vein and again if a trademark is to be protected in all the way the law can it is important to get it registered under proper authority. If you are not willing to protect your trademark there is no need for building one. Precisely because otherwise you won't be able to enjoy any of the following rights, which you will lose only because you didn't get it registered and trademark registration becomes important due to following reasons:

  • Without registration, a latecomer may register a mark identical or similar to the company's mark, which may prevent the unregistered trademark owner to expand his business to other areas with the same trade mark or may block his attempt to register the trademark later. If you cannot stop your competitor from using a trade mark which is the same as or similar to yours, then your competitor may “get a free ride” on your reputation. In many cases, a reputation is the result of having high quality goods or services, providing superior service, or an effective marketing strategy. These usually involve a significant investment in money, time, and know-how.
  • Trademark registration gives the trademark holder to file cases against trade mark violations or abuse of trademark like unfair comparative advertisement.
  • Trademark registration establishes the presumptive right of the trademark owner to use the trademark throughout the country.
  • For those companies that wish to expand internationally, the date of registration may be used as the priority date in other countries, if they are a member of an international treaty, such as the Paris Convention.
  • Discourages others from using confusingly similar marks in the first place by making the mark easy to find in a trademark availability search, thereby preventing problems before they even begin.
  • Protects against registration of confusingly similar marks.
  • Entitles you to certain statutory damages in case of infringement of your trademark related rights.

By registering it becomes part of your valuable asset, and you can sell it, lease it, mortgage it, and transfer it.

By Aruna A.